Friday, January 20, 2006

O Brother, Where Art Thou?


To believe in the Life of Love,
To walk in the Way of Honour,
To serve in the Light of Truth-
This is the Life, the Way and the Light of Sigma Nu-
This is the Creed of our Fraternity.

Yes, it's true. I am an alumnus member of the Kappa Beta chapter of Sigma Nu Fraternity at the University of Western Ontario. I enjoyed my time in the undergraduate "Active" chapter, made a number of lifelong friends and have met people that I never would have under normal circumstances. I'm proud of the founding values and, though I'm not perfect, I try to live each day of my life by the guiding principles of Love, Honour and Truth. But like it or not, my Fraternity is suffering from the same sort of anti-Fraternity sentiment that has caused a decline in membership across almost all the Greek-Letter Societies on campus.

So why do Fraternities and Sororities get such a bad rep at UWO? Is there any truth behind the clichés and stereotypes? What has caused this backlash against these student-run organizations? Let's try and take these on one at a time, shall we? Maybe once we hash this out a bit, things will get a whole lot clearer.

Why do Fraternities and Sororities get such a bad rep at UWO? Because in many cases, they deserve it. People do a lot of stupid things during their university career and members of Fraternities and Sororities are no different. It seems to me that the larger the group, the more likely they are to try and do something akin to the pranks and antics one sees in Animal House. They want their own little slice of immortality in the annals of campus lore. The unfortunate thing is that entire organizations and, in fact, the whole Greek Letter system, can be coloured by the actions of a very small sampling of their membership. In all reality, a frat keg party isn't going to be any wilder or more exciting than one held on Broughdale by OC sophs. But the perception is different. Expectations are higher, so frat members (or possibly even partygoers) may do things they otherwise wouldn't in order to spice things up. There's more anonymity and less accountability under the Fraternity banner. Just remember that everyone is prone to doing stupid things from time to time.

Is there any truth behind the clichés and stereotypes? Absolutely. But again, I believe this has more to do with people wanting to play the role of the typical frat boy or sorority girl. My brothers in the Active chapter were pretty down to earth guys, overall. And certainly not the kind you'd immediately think of as "frat boys." That being said, you're going to find a wide range of people in most Fraternities. There'll be the occasional rich kid who has too much access to daddy's visa. You're going to find the playa out there to nail any woman that breathes. But I bet you could find these same archtypes in just about any club on campus. You'll also find these same kinds of guys at Queen's and they've never allowed Fraternities on campus!

What has caused this backlash against these student-run organizations? It all comes down to conditioning. From the moment a first year student comes on campus, the only information they receive is negative. Last time I checked, Orientation Staff were not permitted to wear their letters on campus (if they were members of a Fraternity or Sorority) during O-Week, nor were they allowed to directly promote or solicit membership or interest. There may also be a well-placed opinion piece or two in the Gazette bashing the Fraternity concept over the course of the year. I would be hardpressed to believe the Gazette editors, though they change every year, will have given up what had become a time-honoured tradition of frat-bashing. As a longtime contributer to the paper during the latter part of my undergraduate days, I know whereof I speak. So unless they go out of their way to seek out the info, students will likely just believe what they've been told, without getting the other side.

There is also no support from the University Students' Council. In days past, the Greek-Letter Societies have attempted to gain status as student organizations, but have been denied. They'll no doubt cite the "exclusivity" of Fraternities as a major reason for this, as well as their affiliation with International organizations. But has one ever stopped to consider that Fraternities are a lot more open and welcoming than they appear at first glance? When I was in the Active Chapter, we had a pretty diverse group, ethnically and religiously speaking speaking. We had Filipinos, Indians, Chinese, and Caucasians who were Christians, Jews, Atheists, or Sikhs. We were more concerned with the kind of person we invited to be a member moreso than skintone or religion.

Let's take a look at the USC now: Although technically anyone can join a USC recognized club, how many Jamaican students do you find in the Chinese Students' Association? Or Muslims joining the Campus Crusade for Christ? Think about that for a moment or two. The biggest difference is that Fraternities ask specific people to join, usually after holding several events to get to know the prospective members. Is the invitation process really the source of all the uproar?

I'm not saying the USC has to fund the Fraternities, not by a longshot. But by the same token, I don't believe it's just to charge them business rates for the use of the UCC Atrium. These are still students trying to promote their student-run organizations. They're also not-for-profit organizations, so give them a break! Give them the same chance to promote themselves as is afforded the Purple Spur Society.

So while we're discussing things anyway, let's take a look at the biggest accusation thrown at fraternities: why do you have to buy your friends? We're not buying our friends. We're paying membership fees, much as any other student does for their club membership. However, in most cases, we're also contributing our share towards the running of the year's social events upfront. Let's take another look at our friends in the Spur. The standard membership fee when I was a member was $20. The pub events were usually $5 at the door, give or take, plus drinking money. There were typically 2-3 pub events in the first term, and then Winter Week (capped off by the infamous ski trip) and the semi-formal. So if one were to attend all the club's activities, without drinking a single beer at the bar, then your total cost for the year would run somewhere in the neighbourhood of $340 or so. That's starting to look alot like lower level Fraternity dues to me. Add in the alcohol for the home football games, the pubs and your ski trip stock, and semi-formal and you're all of a sudden into the $500 range, easily. And once your year is up, it's up. Hmmm... and this club is funded by the USC... At least Fraternity membership extends beyond the undergraduate years. In fact, one of the most reliable of my friends in Montreal is my fraternity brother, Phil. We've hung out more often here than we ever did when I was in London.

So if there's all this negativity focused toward Fraternity life, then what are the benefits? Well, everyone gets something different out of it. For me, I liked the idea that I could be part of something that had a history at Western. I also liked the idea that even though I may leave the city, move on to different things, etc that there would always be something to come back to that felt like home. I wrote for the Gazette for 2 years, but do you think anyone would know me if I walked through the office doors today? Not a chance. But when I walk back into the Fraternity house, I'm welcomed back immediately, whether the brother has ever met me before or not. We've also got a very well developed development program called LEAD (Leadership Ethics Achievement and Development) used during the pledge process. I found that info to be quite helpful once I entered the corporate world. I've also met a variety of alumni who have been helpful as I've tried to make my way in the "real" world, post-university.

Now if you've managed to make it to this part of the posting, then congratulations! Don't worry, I'm wrapping it up now. My whole point in writing this commentary is to provoke some thought. Whether or not you choose to investigate the Fraternity scene is a personal choice. I'm happy I made my choice. The important thing about university is to get involved in something, whether it be the campus Foot Patrol or the Chess Club, just do something. University is about more than just the classes you take and the degree you earn. It's about experiences, memories, and relationships.

20 Comments:

At 1:12 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You make some good points. Especially with the purple spur. Although with the pay-as-you go clubs, it can potentially be more affordable, as you can skip events to save some cash.
Another interesting point I could make is that the greek societies are same-sex. I found that the purple spur definitely had a 'coolness' hierarchy. These people aren't that far removed from high school. The same rules apply. If you're good looking, good with the ladies (or guys) guess what? You're more popular. It would be naive to say that this shouldn't impact your enjoyment of the association. When you go to a pub crawl, and nobody outside the person you came with will give you the time of day because everyone else is clamouring to break into the elite group, it's kind of hard to meet new people. I can't speak to the sorority atmosphere, but when 'the guys' go out, or host a party, there IS no jockeying for position (that is, unless 2 brothers are interested in the same girl ;) ).

 
At 8:46 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great speach Al, you make many excellent points. I've seen this type of anti-Greek discrimination way too much on campus since I came to school back in 1999. Unfortunately, Sigma Nu isn't quite what it was when you left and when I 1st joined. It's become mutated, twisted and sick.It greatly sadens me to see it, but we're dying out and for good reeason. I'd rather go out being what we're supposed to be than become DU just so we can stay alive. I know what I take away from my time in Sigma Nu, and it was worth every penny. Infact, I got a bargain.

 
At 9:30 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

But why do you buy your friends?

 
At 11:35 PM, Blogger Al B Here said...

I didn't buy my friends. I paid a membership fee and paid my share towards the organizing of social events.

 
At 9:47 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Okay, then why do you rent your friends?

 
At 10:04 AM, Blogger Al B Here said...

Nope, no rental involved, either. I paid my membership fees into the organization because I believe in the values of Love, Honour and Truth. I wasn't content to be just a number amongst 26,000 undergraduates. I wanted to be part of something that went beyond Western campus and I found that in Sigma Nu.

 
At 4:54 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nicely put. I stand corrected. May I ask a serious question? In your fraternity, does everybody like each other? Do you dislike anybody in your chapter?

 
At 6:35 PM, Blogger Al B Here said...

It's not really my place to speak for everyone. I also won't look back on the past with rose-coloured glasses, either. I believe that the majority did get along during my stay in the Active chapter. There are some that I was closer to than others, but that stems from a difference in interests and whatnot. We had some tough times and the occasional conflict, but that's life.

 
At 7:19 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

So you buy your enemies too.

 
At 7:50 PM, Blogger Al B Here said...

I don't consider any of them enemies. They're my brothers.

 
At 10:46 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

There's not a single one of those bum-paddling frat boys that you don't like? Give me a break. I was starting to believe your little sermon until you came up with that whopper.

 
At 11:47 PM, Blogger Al B Here said...

Ah yes, the inevitable "bum-paddling frat-boy" comment. I think you've been watching too much Animal House. Aside from its values of Love, Honour and Truth, Sigma Nu was founded as the first Anti-Hazing Fraternity in North America. You'll find no paddling, or bizarre or degrading initiation traditions in our fraternity. We're diametrically opposed to that and have been since the fraternity's inception in 1869 at the Virginia Military Institute. Did I always get along with the brothers? No, I didn't. I've already admitted that. But that doesn't make them (or me) bad people (or me a bad person). I recognize and accept the differences as a part of life.

 
At 8:52 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You term my comment "inevitable" yet you slam me for watching too much Animal House? Listen here Jim Belushi: you are the one that brought up Animal House. I'm only trying to understand something I don't have any direct knowledge of. Excuse me for trying to find out about your elitist little institution.

 
At 11:00 AM, Blogger Al B Here said...

I definitely wouldn't use the term 'elitist' to describe us. After all, my fraternity brother, Morgan, was asked to help found the chapter! And any group that would let him in is certainly not elitist... Ladies and Gentlemen, allow me to unmask my Anonymous Commentator: KB #9, Morgan! You had a good run, mon frère. I just wanted to see how long you'd let the little charade play out.

 
At 7:28 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Et-tu Viktor... I mean Morgan

 
At 12:01 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

That was a good one. By the way, you're payment is late.

 
At 2:38 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Don't you mean "your payment is late?" Dolt.

 
At 10:23 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Please let me edit my typos, @#%!

 
At 9:50 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You make some serious accusations about the Spur. Its a great club, full of great people. The exec yes do seem like they act like they are too cool for people, but that's not the case. The exec have to go through a large application and interviewing process to be accepted on Spur exec, so its not like they are picking the best looking people off the street, who ever applies gets a chance, and they encourage every one of their members to apply each year. They are a group of students who work at least 5 hours a week together to make the club run smoothly, and work overtime together when there's an event coming up. What do you expect from a group of kids who spend so much time together? You do not see the Spur making judgements about the Greek system, and they even work with some of the Greeks to promote their events, not to mention about half of the exec of Spur are Greeks. You should do some more reasearch about who your allies and your enemies are, because you may never know who you may be burning a bridge with.

 
At 7:59 PM, Blogger Al B Here said...

I've made no accusations whatsoever about the Spur. I gave a cost breakdown of attendance to Spur activities, based on the 3 years I was a member of the group. Then I compared the overall cost of club membership to the standard yearly dues in most Western fraternities (as of the early 2000s). No comments were made about the Spur Exec, either, In fact, I ran for Exec on two occasions, so I'm quite familiar with the organization. You may want to take a few deep breaths and reread the information before getting all bent out of shape.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home